The above table was the Council’s consultants’ interpretation of the Preliminary Regional Landfill Site Selection (PRLSS) criteria. All sites were initially examined with reference to the PRLSS criteria. 

A "new" matrix was later adopted by council.  Previously discarded sites were not assessed against the new altered matrix..

 

 Distant from waterways

 Adjacent to Gara river and 4km to World Heritge Oxley Wild Rivers National Park.

Licensed domestic, farm and stock bore approximately 50 metres from site down gradient.

 Council Consultant Mackney

“ The proximity to the Gara River may be perceived by some to be a major impediment”

 Low ground relief

 Council Consultant Maunsell

Slope “ over 30% max- not much below 10%”

 Good surface water control

 Council Consultant Maunsell

“Site situated mid catchment therefore potential for flooding exists. Previous evidence of flooding”

 Good erosion protection 

Council Consultant Maunsell

slopes 10-30%”

Council Consultant Mackney

“…Management of potentially dispersive soils important on this site. Evidence of erodability of local soils evident.”

 Compatibility with adjoining development

 Residences less than 1km from site

 Low agricultural value

 Initial asking price of $1,485,000 for 61 hectares?

 Consultant Maunsell

“Stated valuation of $1.367 million has been provided by the landowner”

 Visually protected

Council Consultant Maunsell

“Partial views of Grafton Road from the site, including a rest-area shelter; The site will require additional screening towards the north in order to minimise potential impacts from the highway”

 Minimal impact on local roadways           

 Single lane Waterfall Way tourist drive. Rated by NRMA in the top 10 drives in NSW.

 Consultant Maunsell

“Increased truck movements on Grafton Rd which is the main route to the coast”

 Adequate road access

 Council Consultant Maunsell

“Site situated mid catchment therefore potential for flooding exists. Previous evidence of flooding”

 Proximity to centres serviced

 Centroid of centres serviced located west of Armidale

 Elevated

 Council Consultant Maunsell

“Site situated mid catchment therefore potential for flooding exists. Previous evidence of flooding”

 Orientation

 Northerly